25 Comments

I think you’re underestimating the grievance/whiny little bitch mentality that seems to have proliferated across the entire GOP base over the last few years. They have completely absorbed Trump’s martyrdom and interpret every “attack” on him as an attack on them, and I think the indictment would probably make him more likely to get the nomination just for that reason. I hope you’re right though because regardless of the politics, that bastard needs to face some justice.

Expand full comment

Remember how much time Democrats spent in 2016 talking about how Clinton's email thing was really no big deal, and the FBI were on a witch hunt? Talking at length about all the crimes our nominee might have done worked out great for us, right?

Expand full comment

I think another reason why the primary would be hell for the GOP is that it would badly divide the GOP base. If DeSantis were to win against Trump somehow (I'm very skeptical even if Trump gets indicted) it would depress a good chunk of the GOP turnout compared to what it would be with a Trump nomination. A lot of those who like Trump REALLY like him and would view a DeSantis bid as a betrayal by him. I live in Macomb County Michigan and what I think both conservative media and mainstream media underestimate based on my experience is how many of his voters not just like him but are extremely passionate about him. They don’t like him because of his policies but because he beats back the libs that want to drastically change the culture of the country. They don’t care about policy and have either forgiven him for his actions during Covid or completely swept it under the rug. During Covid they blamed the House Dems for issuing checks and people not coming back to work instead of the guy who signed those Covid bills into law. It’s all culture war all the time and to them Trump is the most effective culture warrior ever. They can’t imagine anyone else besides Trump running again

All this DeSantis talk is fun but it won’t translate to anything meaningful in real life. If he were to run in 2024 against Trump, strictly from an electoral perspective he’d be Jeb 2.0. He’d be someone viewed favorably by the elites but mostly ignored by the base. Unless things change and Trump decides not to run then I think the 2024 DeSantis nomination is just wishcasting by GOP elites who want Trump gone. Trump leads every poll taken about a hypothetical GOP primary and DeSantis would have to clear the field if he got nominated to have any shot. If I were DeSantis I’d wait until 2028. In 2026 I’d get a cushy Fox News gig to stay in the spotlight and then run for president afterwards. All in all I think that when Trump declares for 2024 DeSantis will eventually kiss the ring and campaign with Trump. If you come for the GOP king you best not miss. If DeSantis ran against Trump and lost both his career and his potential punditry career would be ruined.

Expand full comment

How likely is it that Trump will still be under indictment by 2024 (as opposed to having been acquitted, pled out, literally in prison)? All of those would have different implications I certainly imagine.

Expand full comment

I am the opposite of literate on this subject, but my assumption is that Trump tries to delay court proceedings as much as possible which means he very well might still be under indictment in early 2024.

Expand full comment

Would it help for people like me to say publicly to Trump people, “you can’t have trump and me voting republican. You either get me with DeSantis or me against trump.” I wonder how many trump supporters will take trump over winning the general? Or the other way around.

Expand full comment

Purely anecdotal, but from what I've seen, the true Trump supporters (as opposed to the terrified Republican politicians who feel they have no choice but to worship him if they want to win their primaries and retain their base for the general) really would take Trump over winning the general, because they don't really care about the general, or other candidates besides Trump, and they're convinced he will win if he runs, whether he actually wins or not.

Expand full comment

It's a cult. My best friend works as a roving consultant in Trump country, and has seen people with pictures of Trump on their desks larger than the pictures of their own children. No joke. He's also seen people with handmade TRUMP 2024 banners and flags in their front yards. They literally worship this man.

Expand full comment

Perhaps the people predicting a Trump indictment will make him the nominee are right. But what is their track record for making reliable predictions? Did they see Trump coming in 2015? More humility from prognosticators would be welcome.

Expand full comment

Jeez, what happened to midterms? All of this fairly speculative in an arena where each party's presumptive nominee is a septuagenarian who might well smell toast burning and keel over long before 2024...

Expand full comment

Trump won't conceded defeat if he loses the primary, whereas DeSantis will. For this reason, Trump stands a better chance of winning the general election than DeSantis. Understanding this likelihood (but not really admitting the hostage-situation logic behind it to themselves), Republicans will probably talk themselves into supporting Trump again.

Trump could make this logic brutally clear during a primary: DeSantis would say that Trump was a mixed bag as president but we should move on, while Trump would say that DeSantis is a child molester with an ugly wife whose campaign is secretly funded by Hillary Clinton.

Expand full comment

You’re arguing that trump will do what he did when he was president, which is incite violence to win?

Expand full comment

Spot on here. This primary will be a disaster either way for Republicans. Either the party will begin to eat itself or it nominates Trump with DeSantis sitting out, and Trump is a bad candidate.

Expand full comment

I think it'll be a disaster if there isn't at least a somewhat solid platform. If it's "Trump just wingin' it act three" vs. "sounds of crickets chirping as establishment candidates stare awkwardly at a camera" then it'll be a train wreck. If someone comes prepared, it's potentially game on. But that really remains to be seen.

I think the best possibility for the primary may involve some brokering backstage and a 70/30 praising of Trump's past achievements a la Mao while adopting a new trajectory, as that might flatter Trump out of splitting the general... Though two years is a long way out in politics. I don't think it's impossible that voters could simultaneously entertain the notions that Trump had been done dirty in 2020 and the 2022 raid, but also that he isn't the best pick going forward. But that really requires someone else in the party to have a strong platform for going forward.

Expand full comment

Isn’t it early to assume it’s strictly Trump vs DeSantis? Trump wasn’t even on the radar as a presidential candidate in 2014. In previous contested primaries a lot of the characters that showed up weren’t on the radar until they were in contention (who knew who Rick Santorum was in 2010?) I have a hunch that neither Trump nor DeSantis wins.

Expand full comment

Normally, I would agree with you, but Trump has sucked the oxygen out of the room. Unless he dies (which is possible: he's in his mid-70s and does not take care of himself) or goes to prison (unlikely but also possible), he'll dominate the 2024 race. Tens of millions of Americans worship him.

Expand full comment

While it certainly is early in the cycle, DeSantis is actively catalyzing the behaviors that make Trump popular while also effectively governing the state*. Compare this to someone like Ted Cruz, who is often on mic speaking in a Trump-like manner but failing to turn that performative behavior into any actionable outcome in Congress.

Yes, much can change in the next two years, but DeSantis is keeping his head down doing the work that shows he's more than a soundbite. Unless the base suddenly comes back around to a more moderate party position, he's positioning himself well to ascend if/when Trump is out of the way.

* - Note that while I disagree with his governance, he's clearly got the support of his electorate, hence my assertion that it is effective.

Expand full comment

Consider DeSantis as generic opponent - the story doesn't change significantly with any other specific name. Some are just more plausible than others.

Expand full comment

That’s a good point - other viable candidates?

Expand full comment

Liz Cheney? (/me runs).

Expand full comment

Is it possible that third-party-candidate Cheney can drain away votes from either candidate, thereby imperiling a Republican win?

Expand full comment

There was a poll a couple weeks ago indicating that Cheney would take the overwhelming majority of her votes away from Biden, which sounds correct to me.

Expand full comment

Interesting. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Sound analysis, but why do you presume the 2024 GOP nomination won’t be pretty divisive still w/o Trump? Do you think DeSantis would win easily? I don’t. And other candidates will pull him to the Right/force him to support Trump’s bs

Expand full comment

I recall a comment from a few weeks ago.

Alexander Hamilton may have been on to something.

Expand full comment